Questions we get a lot

Our full current inventory is on eBay, with new listings added every week. Browse the store. We also set up at card shows around Fort Wayne.

Not a retail storefront. We sell primarily online, and we’re at local card shows regularly. Email us and we’ll tell you where we’ll be next.

If a card has a soft corner, a print line, or centering that’s off, it’s in the listing. That’s based off of PSA guidelines, and Alan and Matt both check out raw cards personally. If a card arrives and it isn’t what the listing said, tell us and we’ll make it right.

Every order is packed by hand, with the card protected the way we’d want ours protected. Shipping details and current turnaround are on each eBay listing.

Please do. A single card gets the same attention as a large collection. If you’re buying a first card for a kid, tell us the player and the budget and we’ll point you somewhere sensible.

Yes. Vintage from before 1980 and modern from 1980 on, single cards through full collections. Here’s how it works.

Bulk commons from the 1980s and ’90s. We’re well stocked, and we’d rather tell you that than make an offer that isn’t worth your time. Everything else, let’s talk.

Condition plus recent sold prices: what cards like yours actually sold for, card by card.

For larger collections that need us to come out, there’s a small fee based on time and distance. It’s waived if we end up buying the collection.

Yes. We consign at competitive rates: we handle photos, listings, questions and shipping, and agree on payout terms with you before anything is listed. Email us and we’ll walk through the terms, or read how consignment works.

Within 72 hours. If you haven’t heard from us by then, write or call again. Something went wrong on our end.